Seeking Signs of The Times

MARTIN CAREY | Licensed Marriage and Family Therapist and Life Assurance Ministries Board Member |

Growing up Adventist, I remember living in an atmosphere of expectation. On Sabbath mornings we heard exciting mission stories, heard of Mrs. White’s visions, and we believed that signs and wonders were happening, here and away out there in the mission field. Those stories affirmed my Adventist identity that was rooted in the wondrous events of our church’s founding. Those experiences of the Adventist pioneers were portrayed as more than miracles. We believed that Ellen White’s visions were a sign of God-given authority as the prophet for the last days of earth’s history. Most exciting for me were her vivid and frightening descriptions of last day events that we expected to explode on us any day. What signs of the end should we pay attention to, and what were we missing? There was much intense speculation and many strong opinions expressed in Sabbath School and in everyday conversations. Who was able to accurately read the signs of the end times?

Two thousand years ago, Jesus gave us the signs of the end of the age, along with instructions for how we are to read the signs of the times. The religious leaders of His time did not accept His authority and message and tried to entrap him by demanding a sign from heaven.

After Jesus’ ascension to heaven, God gave many miraculous signs to the apostles as a witness for spreading the gospel. In contrast, those leaders seeking a heavenly sign from Jesus were looking for confirmation of their unbelief. They were not receiving Jesus with faith, but seeking reasons to disbelieve. The Pharisees and Sadducees did not accept Jesus as Messiah, because He was not the kind of Messiah they wanted—a messiah who would give glory to them (John 12:42,43). While their Maker and Husband (Isaiah 54:5) walked in their midst, raising the dead and opening blind eyes, they rejected Him (Isaiah 53:1-3). That is why Jesus called them “wicked and adulterous.” Their unbelief blinded them to the genuine signs of the times. 

It’s easy to condemn the Pharisees while missing lessons from more recent history, closer to home. When deeply sincere, religious people don’t know Jesus as the divine Son of God (Jn. 1:1; 8:58) or believe the gospel of His atonement for the forgiveness of sins (1 Cor. 15:1-5), they can be as blind to seeing the real Jesus as those Pharisees. They will invent another Jesus, embrace another gospel, and receive another spirit (1Corinthians 11:2-5). Without the Spirit’s guidance, our passions will control our deepest longings and blind us to spiritual reality. 

In Matthew 12, the religious leaders had also tried to trap Jesus, and He gave an answer that applies to all who resist believing in Him: 

For those who are not accepting His full divinity and His authority to complete His work in the gospel, Jesus has one sign for them: the sign of the prophet Jonah. Jonah descended into the deep inside the great fish as a type of Christ’s death and resurrection. That was the sign of the times for the unbelieving then, and it remains the one sign we need now. We can forever chase after signs with great zeal and never come to terms with the offense of the Cross. As Paul said, 

While we can be impressed with the Millerites’ zeal for Christ’s return, we need to consider their theology of the gospel. Miller’s gospel had an incomplete atonement that remained unfinished until sin has been actually cleansed from sinners. Miller reasoned that Jesus’ death on the cross could not have completed the atonement, for His sacrifice did not immediately cleanse the earth of all sin. Miller even denied that Jesus was functioning as priest while giving His life on the cross, because there were no priests there to officiate at his sacrifice. In contrast, see Hebrews10:14, where “He offered Himself without blemish to God”. Miller denied atonement was made at the cross, and stated, 

Miller saw Day of Atonement language into Daniel 8:14, assuming that text was a prophecy of the Day of Atonement in Leviticus 16 being fulfilled in 1843. He based his multi-step atonement theory on the complex system of sacrifices on the ancient Day of Atonement. The end result of all his chaotic proof-texting and complex reasoning was a gospel where Christ’s death was only the “sacrifice for atonement,” not an actual complete atonement for our sins. Therefore, the sins of believers could not be blotted out at conversion, but in the future when sin is fully overcome in their lives. 

Ellen White further develops Miller’s theology of gradual atonement with her probationary forgiveness. Believers are not actually fully forgiven, she stated, but are placed on probation until their obedience becomes acceptable (EGW, Spirit of Prophecy, 49). If the blood of Christ cannot cancel sin, but is merely the polluted vehicle by which our sins are transported to heaven to await an investigative judgment, our guilt remains and our standing with God is uncertain. Ellen White stated,

Under this scheme, we do not have the forgiveness of sins, we have only uncertain hoping and striving for perfection so that God will accept our efforts and forgive us. It is certainly not the gospel of Jesus, who promised us full forgiveness and acceptance from the day we first believe in Him. There is no fear of future judgment. In His own words,

In Hebrews, the writer contrasts the weakness and drudgery of the Old Covenant with the power of Christ’s single sacrifice in the New Covenant. If Ellen White was right about our sins not being cancelled, but kept on record in heaven, then we have little advantage over the poor guilty Israelite, dragging his animals to the temple, but never having the peace of a clean conscience. No, we have a new covenant. When we trust in Jesus and confess our sins to Him, believing that His sacrifice is enough, we are counted as righteous, as perfect, before God, and we are born again by the Spirit to a new life of loving our neighbor. Trusting in the one sacrifice of Jesus cancels all sins and removes all guilt, forever. 

He sat down, by the Father, having perfected all those who are being sanctified. So does God keep a record of our sins in His Most Holy Place, until we prove ourselves? The writer goes on to say in vs 17,

This is the ever-present truth we need for our troubled conscience. That is the gospel that brings the power of God unto salvation. When we resist the pure gospel of Jesus’ once-for-all atonement, we are resisting God’s wonder-working power to save us from our sins.    

From its beginnings, Adventism has resisted the pure gospel of the cross and the forgiveness of sins. The original gospel, given by apostolic authority and cherished by the Christian church for 1800 years, was reshaped by Adventism into another gospel of tentative forgiveness and probationary striving. The Millerites were crushed with disappointment because they did not correctly read the signs of the times. They did not understand that the last days; the “end of the age” had already begun, 1800 years before. Hebrews 9:26 tells us,

I have an elderly client who suffers from severe depression and anxiety, is afraid to die, and asked for a Christian counselor. She told me she doesn’t know if God loves her or has forgiven her sins. She was raised Catholic and does not know much Scripture, so I took her through the gospel texts about Jesus dying for our sins, how we confess our sins and believe in Jesus, and how we can never earn God’s forgiveness. This poor woman hears those passages and cries, feeling sad and guilty, and has trouble believing that she is forgiven. She is starting to accept that there is nothing she can do to earn God’s forgiveness, that eternal life is free because Jesus paid of her life, while peace is elusive. I just keep telling her about God’s promises, how some of God’s children suffer, and to never give up talking to God, even if all she can do is cry out to Him. She agrees that she will. 

Like my suffering client, we all must be rescued from the pit of unbelief. Saving faith doesn’t come naturally for any of us. I can personally relate to the desperation of my client, and also to that poor father who asked Jesus to heal his demon-possessed son, saying, “if you can do anything.” 

My friend, do you believe that God can forgive your sins, completely cancel them, and remember them no more? Trust His words by asking Him to help your unbelief. He will. †

Martin Carey
Latest posts by Martin Carey (see all)

Leave a Reply