XIII. The Decalogue Not Eternal.

Adventists contend that the Ten Commandments are perfect in character, eternal in duration, universal in application, and unalterable in nature. We shall now make inquiry as to the reliability of these pretentious claims. Read Ex. 20: 1-17.

PERFECT IN CHARACTER.

By this statement they mean that the Ten Commandments enjoin every good and forbid every evil. A great claim, this. It is literally impossible, per their theory, to commit a sin that is not a direct violation of one of these ten commands.

But against this contention we note the following:

Adultery.—The seventh of these Ten Commandments says: “Thou shalt not commit adultery.” Adultery is unlawful intercourse of a married person with any one else—that is to say, adultery is a species of sexual sins; that is to say, further, that adultery is not the genus, covering all sexual sins, but one of the many. That there are sexual sins other than adultery is evident when we call attention to the following:

  1. Abomination—lying “with mankind as with womankind.” (Lev. 18: 22.)
  2. Confusion—lying “with any beast to defile thyself therewith.” (Lev. 18: 23.)
  3. Fornication—unlawful intercourse of a single person with another. (1 Cor. 5: 1.)
  4. Self-abuse.

Lying.—The eighth command forbids bearing false witness “against” thy “neighbor.” Bearing false witness for a “neighbor” is not forbidden. Bearing false witness against an alien is not forbidden. The reader may be inclined to think that this is going to extremes; but when we point out a few of the differences, as held by the Jews, between one of themselves and an alien, the extreme will evidently vanish. That there was a great “middle wall of partition” in this respect is seen by the following facts:

  1. Soured meat could be sold to an alien, but not to a Jew. (Deut. 14: 21.)
  2. Alien slaves could be held forever, but Hebrew slaves had to be released every seven years. (Lev. 25: 45; Deut. 15: 12-18.)
  3. Money could be loaned to aliens “upon usury,” but not to a Jew. (Deut. 23: 20.)

Thus there was a difference between a Jew and one who was not a Jew; and thus false witness was forbidden as regards the Jew. Nothing is said relative to the alien.

Images.—In the Old Testament there are three kinds of images (1) the graven (Ex. 20: 4), (2) the molten (Ex. 34: 17), and (3) pictures (Num. 33: 52).

The Ten Commandments forbid only the first of these—the “graven”—and possibly the third by the use of the word “likeness.”

Murder.—The sixth command forbids killing. It says nothing about hate, envy, jealousy, anger, or the like.

THE TEN COMMANDMENTS FORBID OVERT ACTS, BUT ARE SILENT RELATIVE TO MOTIVES THAT LEAD TO THE ACTS—EXCEPT IN THE CASE OF COVETING.

Adultery, the act, is forbidden; lust, the motive, is not.

Killing, the act, is forbidden; hate, the motive, is not.

But stealing, the act, is forbidden; and coveting, the motive, also is forbidden. This is the exception.

But an Adventist argues like this: “Before one can commit adultery he must lust, and before one can kill he must hate; hence lust is forbidden in adultery and hate in kill.”

But over against this contention we point out this fact: “Before one can steal he must first covet; hence, per the foregoing contention, coveting, the motive, is forbidden in stealing, the act.” But this is precisely what is not so. There are only ten commands in the decalogue, and one of these, the eighth, forbids stealing; while another, the tenth, forbids coveting. Had this plan been carried out relative to adultery and killing, there would have been two more commands in the Ten Commandments, one being, “Thou shalt not hate,” and the other, “Thou shalt not lust.”  But these commands are wanting.

The Ten Commandments, therefore, do not forbid every evil.

ETERNAL IN DURATION.

By eternal in duration Adventists mean that the Ten Commandments always have existed as found in Ex. 20: 1-17, and that they always will exist as found there. They mean that the Ten Commandments were honored and obeyed eternities before the world was created, and that through eternity all the redeemed will be subject to them. Touching on this contention, we point out the following:

The name of a thing cannot exist before the thing itself. In Gen. 2 we are told that God created all things and brought them to Adam for names. To make our point absurdly simple, let us state that up to that time there was no such animal as “cow.” But when Adam said, “This one shall henceforth be called ‘cow,'” that very moment cows came into being; and at that time the other living creatures received names in like manner.

Thus is it obvious that the thing itself may exist eternities without a name, but it is also obvious that the name of a thing cannot exist unless the thing itself is in existence. If the reader doubts this, we ask him to name something that he knows does not exist! Assuming, then, that we are all agreed on this point, we note the following facts:  

  1. There was a time when there was only one God (Jehovah). At that time the expression, “other gods,” found in the second command of the Decalogue, could not have had existence.
  2. There was a time when there were no images, for there were no other gods. At that time the expression, “graven images,” found in the second command of the Decalogue, could not have had existence.
  3. There was a time, before the days of Adam and Eve, when there were no fathers and mothers. At that time the expressions “father” and “mother” could not have had existence.
  4. There was a time, before the days of Cain, when no one had been killed. At that time the word “kill,” the name of an action found in the Ten Commandments, could not have had existence.

We might go on ad infinitum with this list.

Imagine Jehovah, eternities before the world was created, attempting to teach the Ten Commandments, as found in Ex. 20: 1-17, to the angels about his throne. What questions would they have asked when he came to “other gods,” “graven images,” “the earth beneath,” “fathers,” “children,” “generation,” “hate,” “land,” “kill,” “adultery,” “steal,” “covet?” This is an amusing question if you will carry it the full length.

The Ten Commandments, therefore, are not eternal in duration.  

UNIVERSAL IN APPLICATION.

By universal in application Adventists mean that the Ten Commandments have been intended for, and have actually extended in authority to, every nation on the face of the earth from time eternal. We deny this contention for the following reasons:

  1. Jehovah, on Sinai, spoke ten words-no more, no less. So declares Deut. 10: 4 (margin). Such is the meaning of “decalogue” —deca, “ten;” and logoi, “words”-“ten words!”
  2. These ten words were spoken to Israel. “I am the Lord thy God, which have brought thee out of the land of Egypt.” No other nation has been delivered from Egyptian bondage by Jehovah.
  3. The laws of the Jews extended to Gentiles only when Gentiles became proselytes to the Jewish religion. (Ex. 12.) There was then “one law” for all.
  4. The legal system of the Jews is limited to Israel. (Deut. 4: 8.) No other nation had this law.
  5. The Sabbath was given for a special purpose to the Jews. (Ex. 31: 13.)
  6. The Gentiles, until the time of Christ, were aliens from the commonwealth of Israel, were strangers to all the privileges of the Jews, had no hope, and were without God. (Eph. 2: 12.)

The Ten Commandments, therefore, were not universal in application.   

UNALTERABLE IN NATURE.

By unalterable in nature Adventists mean that the Ten Commandments shall stand just as they read in Ex. 20: 1-17, to every jot and tittle, as long as heaven and earth shall stand.

Their first proof of this is an assumption—an assumption that the Ten Commandments are perfect. But we have already eliminated this assumption. We note the following:

Oaths.—The third command deals exclusively with the use of God’s name in the practice of making oaths. Israel, as a nation, were commanded to use God’s name in making oaths. “Thou shalt swear by my name.” (Deut. 6: 13.) But “thou shalt not swear by my name falsely.” (Lev. 19: 12.) Putting these two commands together, we have the third command of the Decalogue: “Thou shalt not take the name of the Lord thy God in vain.”

Consider this on the question of taking oaths: Abraham sent his servant to find a wife for Isaac. But before the servant left, Abraham said: “I will make thee swear by the Lord.” (Gen. 24: 3.) The servant then made his oath, putting his hand on Abraham’s thigh (which was the custom then instead of holding his right hand up), thereby taking God’s name—calling upon God as his witness. But the servant did not take God’s name “in vain,” for he performed the oath—did the thing he swore he would do.

And note the case of Rahab, the harlot. Joshua sent two spies to Jericho. They lodged with Rahab, the harlot. When they were ready to leave, she demanded: “Swear unto me by the Lord.” (Josh. 2: 12.) And after an interval they took their leave of her, but said: “We will be guiltless of this thine oath which thou hast made us swear.” In this statement they used the identical expression found in the third command of the Decalogue: “For the Lord will not hold him guiltless,” etc.

To use God’s name, therefore, was to swear by his name; and to use his name in vain was to swear and not perform the oath.

Our Lord eliminated the third command of the Decalogue entirely. I refer to his Sermon on the Mount. “I say unto you, Swear not at all.” (Matt. 5: 32.) The Ten Commandments permitted swearing where the oath was performed. Jesus forbade even that. This applies among Christians. This has nothing to do with taking oaths in court.

The “land” of the fifth command was the land of Canaan. This land was promised to Abraham two hundred and fifteen years before the Egyptian bondage. (Gen. 13: 14.) Moses stated that Canaan was “the lot” of Israel’s “inheritance.” (1 Chron. 16: 18.) Christians have no promise of the land of Canaan. Our land is “the heavenly country.”

Take the matter of remembering sins. In the second command Jehovah states that he remembered the “sins of the fathers” against the “third and fourth generations.” The children of wicked parents were required to confess the sins of their ancestors to the fourth generation. (Lev. 26: 40.) But in the New Testament this requirement is removed. Now he remembers “their sins and their iniquities” to the third and fourth generations “no more.” (Heb. 8: 6-13.) Thus each one of us must now give account “of himself unto God.” (Rom. 14: 12.)

The Ten Commandments, therefore, are not unalterable in nature.

We have found, then, that the Ten Commandments are neither perfect in character, eternal in duration, universal in application, nor unalterable in nature. †


CONTENTS

Former Adventist
Latest posts by Former Adventist (see all)

Leave a Reply