Biblical Verdict: Ellen White Failed (Q4 L9)

Lesson 9: “Testing the Prophets”

COLLEEN TINKER | Editor, Proclamation! | 

Adventist, how do YOU defend Ellen White’s prophetic claims? What makes you sure she was God’s messenger to Adventism and to the world in these last days? What does she give you that the simple gospel of Jesus’ death for sin, His burial, and His resurrection cannot give you? What would you lose if Ellen turned out to be a FALSE prophet? How would that fact change your life and your identity? 

Today we are reviewing Lesson 9 in the fourth quarter’s Sabbath School curriculum for 2026. The lesson is entitled “Testing the Prophets”, and the entire week is dedicated to “proving” that Ellen G White is a true prophet of God in the order of Jonah, Jeremiah, Isaiah, and Paul. 

Evaluation Tools

The Teachers Comments again offer the most succinct summary of Adventism’s methods of evaluating Ellen White’s prophetic identity. The first paragraph of the comments say this: 

Those “other tests” that the author claims can be applied to “verify the prophetic gift” include the “prophetic call” of the prophet, the prophet’s “uncompromising truthfulness”, “supernatural signs and evidence”, and the prophet’s legacy of “edification and spiritual benefit”. 

According to this lesson itself, the four main tests of a prophet’s legitimacy are “alignment with Scripture, Christ-centered testimony, fulfilled predictions, and life/ministry fruits”. Using these as our measuring rod, let’s see how Ellen actually does.

Alignment with Scripture

To establish what it means that a prophet must align with Scripture, let’s look at the Bible’s first and clearest definition of a true prophet and of a false prophet. Let’s also see how this passage reveals that there is a time element to our evaluation of a prophet. Here is Deuteronomy 18:15–22:

Moses was preparing for his death and for passing the baton of leadership of the nation of Israel to Joshua as they would go into the Promised Land. The very first application of Moses’ directive would be fulfilled in the person of Joshua, Moses’ immediate successor and the One through whom the Yahweh would lead His nation. Further, throughout the future of the nation as recorded in the rest of the Old Testament, God raised up prophets from among the Israelites and delivered His instructions to them. 

This very passage revealed how Israel was expected to evaluate whether or not the prophetic voices that claimed to speak for God actually DID speak for God or not. We realize, as we read of the collapse of Israel and Judah, that false prophets DID arise—but they spoke what the wicked kings wanted to hear. They did not reveal God’s words to them nor speak according to the Mosaic covenant terms. 

Yet this prophecy of Moses had a far future application as well. In the New Testament we read: 

As Peter preached to the Jews in Solomon’s Portico shortly after the Day of Pentecost, he specifically told the Jews that the Lord Jesus had been the fulfillment of Moses’ prophecy that a prophet like him would arise from among the Israelites and be the One to whom they were to listen. The legacy of prophets in Israel began with Moses and ended with the Lord Jesus. All the prophets God called in the intervening years created the line of Israelite people whom Yahweh called and through whom He delivered His warnings, His calls of repentance, and His revelations for the future of the nation—including His promise to send the Messiah who would die for their sins and be raised from death, and His new covenant promise which He delivered through Moses, Jeremiah, and Ezekiel! 

In fact, Jesus even announced the end of the prophet period of God’s revelation to the nation. In Luke 16:16 we read Jesus saying to the Jews: 

Jesus specifically, directly said that the Law—the entire Mosaic Covenant including the Ten Commandments which had been mediated by Moses—and the prophets “were until John”—a reference to John the Baptist. Since John’s announcement to the nation, the kingdom of God has been preached! 

Who was preaching the kingdom of God? It was Jesus Himself! After His fulfillment of the Old Covenant by means of His death, burial, resurrection and ultimately His ascension, the Lord Jesus sent the Holy Spirit to His disciples, and the apostles and prophets who had been filled with the Holy Spirit laid the foundation of the church (Ephesians 2:20). The very words of the apostles which Jesus gave them were the words of life that became the gospel teaching of the new covenant and the source of our saving knowledge of Jesus (John 17:20). 

The New Covenant prophets included in the founding of the church were not receiving new information from God that He hadn’t previously given. They were preaching the very words that the Lord Jesus had given to His disciples which were the words through which all believers “downstream” would believe in Him! In fact, the new covenant prophets described in 1 Corinthians 14 are not prophets like Jeremiah and Isaiah. They are people whom the Lord gifts with His indwelling Spirit to speak His word—His already-given word recorded in the New Testament. New Testament prophets are gifted by God according to His will (1 Corinthians 12:11) to encourage and build up the body of Christ as needed, applying the new covenant gospel truths to people’s situations and dilemmas. New Covenant prophets are not given new revelations or explanations of the “plan of salvation” or of the nature of God and His purposes or of our own human condition. 

On the contrary: God’s last prophet to the world who revealed God purposes and the way of salvation is the Lord Jesus Himself—the One who was coming and mediating a new covenant “like Moses”. Moses mediated the Law—the old covenant—and Jesus mediated the new covenant. His fulfillment of the old covenant and His inauguration of the new covenant in His blood is God’s final word to us! Hebrews 1:1, 2 tells us this truth:

What we see in Scripture, therefore, is that God spoke to His people through prophets in times past, delivering to them His will and His word by means of human voices. In these last days since Jesus’ ascension, however He has spoken to us in His Son. The Lord Jesus is God’s final prophetic word to us. He revealed the new covenant. Everything that follows in the New Testament is the explanation of how God’s purposes work in the world in the administration of the new covenant. 

Yet what did Ellen say about herself? She placed her writings into that text of Hebrews:  

Ellen claimed prophetic status for herself. She claimed that God was speaking through HER in the last days!

This claim ALONE disqualifies Ellen White as a prophet who passes the biblical test! She not only claims to have prophetic authority in the order of the Old Testament prophets, but she inserted he own writings into the passage that echoed Hebrews 1:1,2 which overtly states that God speaks through the Son in the last days! 

Unbiblical Teachings

The heart of Ellen White’s unbiblical teaching concerns the atonement accomplished by the Lord Jesus—the gospel. She denied that Jesus completed the atonement at the cross but instead said His atonement is being made now in heaven as He applies the blood to the confessed sins of the saved: 

Further, Ellen stated repeatedly that Satan is the “scapegoat” on whom the Lord Jesus will place the sins of the saved. In this way, Satan will be the final sin-bearer and will be punished for our sins. This idea is blasphemy. The Lord Jesus became sin for us (2 Corinthians 5:21) and fully paid the price for our sins. Satan NEVER bears our sins or is punished for them! See what she said: 

Space does not permit us show all the heresies of Ellen White’s persistent teachings, including her refusal ever to embrace the biblical Trinity but instead declaring that the “godhead” is “the heavenly Trio” and “the Three Worthies of Heaven”. She further said that Jesus came and took the fallen flesh of humanity, having the inherited propensities to evil that He received from Mary’s heritage. She also said that man has no immaterial spirit but that he ceases to exist at death, and she taught that Jesus came to vindicate the law and to demonstrate that we, too can keep it. She even declared that keeping the commandments is required for being God’s child, and the seventh-day Sabbath is the seal of God and the sign that a person is loyal to God, the mark of those who will be saved when Jesus returns. 

We can see with just these few examples that Ellen White does NOT pass the test of being a prophet who is true to Scripture. From her very claim to BE God’s last-day messenger to her Satan-centric teachings that move Jesus aside from being the final sin-bearer and to the importance of an ongoing work of the law in the new covenant, Ellen White reveals herself to be a false prophet. She taught a false, fallible Jesus who did not complete the atonement on the cross. She taught a weak God who risked the entire Trinity by sending His Son without knowing if he would actually be able to complete His mission. She taught an unbiblical definition of humanity and taught Sabbath-keeping as the key to salvation, never teaching that we are born dead in sin and must be made alive through being born of God. 

Her message was not Christ-centered because her “Christ” is not eternal Yahweh who never gave up any aspect of His divine attributes, including omnipresence. Furthermore, the fruit of her ministry had no choice but to be divisive and dark. Since she did not teach or practice biblical reality, her function within the Adventist organization yielded conflict and division. 

There is one more category of prophet-testing that we must address. J. Henry Monk, a former Seventh-day Adventist who lived during Ellen White’s lifetime, wrote a book entitled Adventism and The Bible in 1919, four years after the prophet died. In chapter VII, entitled “The Testimonies of Mrs. White”, he included this: 

I have included this quote from Henry Monk to show that Ellen White’s contemporaries did not share a rosy belief in her as a voice from God. Instead, her own testimonies reveal that the people she was attempting to influence resented her, refused to comply, disbelieved her, argued and disagreed with her and were moving away from believing her altogether. Her testimonies reveal that she was struggling to keep control of the Adventist juggernaut. 

These characteristics do not fit the tests of a prophet of God. Yes, God’s prophets were often mocked and reviled during the times they lived, but their messages recorded in Scripture reflected God’s covenant terms with His people. Ellen White’s rebukes reflected a woman who was manipulative and who used gaslighting and spiritual abuse to coerce people into compliance. There is a great difference between a biblical prophet declaring eternal truths that God had delivered from the beginning and a modern “prophet” delivering testimonies intended to guilt and shame people into doing her bidding. Ellen’s threats that people would leave God altogether if they failed to listen to her is utterly unbiblical.

Her theological and doctrinal writings are heretical and blasphemous, deviating from Scripture widely, teaching a false god, a fallible Jesus, an incomplete atonement, and Satan as the final sin-bearer who is punished for our sins. These teachings alone disqualify her as a prophet of God! 

In summary, I appeal to you, Adventist: be reconciled to God. Come to Him on the basis of Jesus’ shed blood alone, for you cannot please God by Sabbath-keeping and sincerity. You, like all of us, are born dead in sin, and each of us must be born again. 

Come to Jesus and see Him taking your sin in His body on the cross, enduring God’s wrath for your sin, dying your death as God pours out His judgment for your sin on His Son. See Him rise on the third day because His sacrifice was sufficient to fully pay the penalty for your sin! Throw yourself on His mercy and thank Him for taking your sin and paying fully for it. 

Repent for your belief that you had to believe the teachings of a false prophet. Repent of your attachment with Adventism and ask God to remove the spirit of Adventism from your heart and to place His Spirit where Adventism had been. Thank Jesus for His complete atonement and ask Him to plant you deeply in truth and reality and to give you a love for His word.

Trust Jesus alone. He is all you need, and when you do, you will never be the same. The burden of Ellen and her moralisms will roll off of you, and you will be born again with the life of the risen Christ in you! I urge you, Adventist—trust Jesus—and LIVE! †

This weekly feature is dedicated to Adventists who are looking for biblical insights into the topics discussed in the Sabbath School lesson quarterly. We post articles which address each lesson as presented in the Sabbath School Bible Study Guide, including biblical commentary on them. We hope you find this material helpful and that you will come to know Jesus and His revelation of Himself in His word in profound biblical ways.

Colleen Tinker
Latest posts by Colleen Tinker (see all)

Leave a Reply