Need Help with the Investigative Judgment and Adventist Soul Sleep
I have a couple questions in regards to the investigative judgment doctrine and the state of the soul. Just for some context I’m a born again Christian, not a Seventh-day Adventist. I’ve been a Christian for about three years now, and I didn’t know much about Adventism until about a year ago, where I learned one of my childhood friends has been an Adventist and has been taking his Adventist faith super seriously. So I did a deep dive, and at first, I thought Adventists were just Christians who went to church on Saturday, which I didn’t see a problem with, but then I started going deeper and deeper into the doctrines, and almost immediately I saw the red flags—the beliefs that Ellen White is inspired and that the atonement didn’t end with the death and resurrection of Jesus Christ as well as with the state of the soul.
That’s the biggest issue, in my opinion—saying that the atonement is ongoing is absolutely crazy, so I really come hard against the investigative judgment doctrine in my conversations with my buddy. In all honesty, I haven’t had bad experiences with Adventists as a people; they’ve been super nice and open to a dialogue about their faith, and I’ve been to a few church services and young adults’ stuff which has been pretty cool as far as social gatherings go (I’m 23). But I keep a close eye and ear about what’s being preached, and by the Holy Spirit I’m able to discern error within the preaching and teaching. (I’ll usually goto services with my buddy.)
I live in a large metropolitan area, so I’m not sure if it’s different in other places around the United States but it almost seems like the modern state of Adventist churches is more like non-denominational churches. From what I’ve gathered, the modern-day Adventism is not really like how it was even 50 years ago. The Adventist churches I’ve been to still hold fast of the doctrine of the church, but from what I have gathered, it’s a little more “liberal”, not liberal as in rainbow flags, LGBT, but liberal Adventist. From the people I’ve talked to in the Adventist church, it seems like my being a non-Adventist isn’t a problem, and from their perspective, I’ll still be saved—I think. From what I’ve learned about hard-core original Adventism, it’s almost like if you’re not an Adventist, then you’re outside of salvation.
I’ve read Dale Ratzlaff’s book CulticDoctrine, so I have a little bit of an idea about the investigative judgment and the state of the soul. I’ve seen some of his teachings, and I’ve also listened to his book Truth Led Me Out.
He and other ex-Adventists like him have really helped me get a look at what Adventism is like and at the nature of the doctrines. Dale passed away just about a year after I got saved. I love his teachings, and I look forward to seeing him in heaven.
My question is, do you have any good resources on the investigative judgment that are somewhat quick and concise. The same goes for the state of the soul. For me as a Christian it seems so simple that Jesus’ work was finished on the cross and that people have an immaterial spirit that lives on after death, but I’m trying to gather resources to show my friend so that he can understand it.
His big issue and challenge to me; he wants me to show him from the Greek that spirit/soul means an immaterial spirit that goes on after we die. He tells me that it just means “breath” and not the immaterial spirit like how we Christians see it. Also, if you have good Scriptures that show it that would be great too.
I apologize for the long email. Thank you for all your work on YouTube, and I’m blessed that the Lord Jesus saved and uses you to show many ex-Adventists the truth of God’s word.
—VIA EMAIL
Response: Thank you for writing. Adventist will try very hard to convince you that the human spirit is merely a force from God—literally one’s breath—that enlivens us when we breath and leaves us essentially non-existant when we die. They hide the truth about their beliefs from “outsiders” and twist Scripture to appear to have biblical support for their ideas. Yet their underlying belief that they cease to exist (except as a memory in God’s mind) when they die is the essential foundation of all Adventist doctrine and practice. It all comes from their underlying belief that God is not the Trinity of Scripture. Foundational Adventism believes on the basis of all the Adventist founders that God is physical and has, as James White wrote in 1846, body, parts, and passions in direct contradiction of the classic Christian belief that He does NOT have body and parts!
This anti-trinitarian belief IS THE FOUNDATION OF EVERY SEVENTH-DAY ADVENTIST DOCTRINE. Every single doctrine was formed on the foundation of a physical God that was comprised of three beings—or, as White said originally—two beings and a “force”, or Holy Spirit.
Over the years Adventism refined its trinitarian belief to sound close to trinitarianism, but Ellen White and the denomination never accepted the classic Trinity that teaches one God with three persons who share essence or substance. Rather, Ellen taught the “heavenly Trio”, or “the Three Worthies of Heaven” who are separate beings united in purpose and will. They do NOT share substance. And never has the Adventist organization renounced its original anti-trinitarianism. It merely submerged it and gradually printed amended statements. Today there is a great resurgence toward anti-trinitarainsm.
While there can be significant variation among Adventists geographically and by congregation, their arguments and personal statements are still growing out of their Arian, anti-trinitarian root. All Adventists believe that God does not share “essence” or “substance”. The official Adventist organizational website compares Him to a “winning team”, a group of person who come to our aid. Today’s Adventist scholars have written several books and papers—prominently Jerry Moon of Andrews University and Kwabena Donkor whose paper on the Adventist trinity is on their Biblical Research website—stating that Ellen White’s “heavenly trio” is the correct view of the Trinity. Adventist scholars affirm that she never endorsed the Christian Trinity but that her Trio view is the correct view.
Flowing out of this idea is the belief that humans are bodies that breathe. Our breath is our “spirit”. When our breath ceases, we cease to exist, like the picture on a television disappears from existence when the plug is pulled.
Yet look at John 4:24 and John 5:24–29.
Here is a link to an article that may help you understand how to “see” and address this Adventist worldview: https://lifeassuranceministries.org/2021/05/27/are-humans-more-than-living-bodies/
What Does This Passage Mean?
Good morning, is there anything to which you could point me to help me grasp this better as a Christian, not a Seventh-day Adventist?
…and He gave Him authority to execute judgment, because He is the Son of Man. “Do not marvel at this; for an hour is coming, in which all who are in the tombs will hear His voice, and will come forth; those who did the good deeds to a resurrection of life, those who committed the evil deeds to a resurrection of judgment.—John 5:27–29
—VIA EMAIL
Response: Thank you for writing. This passage is Jesus saying that the Father has given Him the right to judge the earth. In the context, He has been given the authority to judge the earth because He has taken a human nature and has paid the full price for human sin and has broken the curse of death into which all of us are born. He had to be a human in order to pay this price because only human blood could pay for human sin—could satisfy God’s own demand that the wages of sin is death. Because God’s judgment for sin was accomplished in the Lord Jesus on the cross and is credited to every person who believes and trusts Him alone, He has the right to judge those who do not believe. Those who don’t trust the Son alone are judged guilty and under the death sentence. Those who believe are removed from the death sentence because Jesus took it for them.
Verses 24—27 are part of the context for verse 28. Jesus says:
“Truly, truly, I say to you, he who hears My word, and believes Him who sent Me, has eternal life, and does not come into judgment, but has passed out of death into life. Truly, truly, I say to you, an hour is coming and now is, when the dead will hear the voice of the Son of God, and those who hear will live. For just as the Father has life in Himself, even so He gave to the Son also to have life in Himself; and He gave Him authority to execute judgment, because He is the Son of Man.”—John 5:24–27 LSB
First, Jesus is saying that the person who hears HIM and believes the One who sent Him (that’s the Father) HAS eternal life and does not come into judgment. He has passed out of death into life. Notice the verb tense: “Has passed”: present perfect. This means that is happened at the moment of belief and continues without a break. Passing from death to life happens when a person hears and believes the Lord Jesus and God’s word about our salvation in Christ.
Even more, we, as spiritually dead people, pass out of death at that moment and do not come into judgment. We are saved when we believe, and nothing can place us under judgment for sin again. Jesus had taken our guilt and death sentence, and we pass out of death into life.
In verse 25 Jesus is saying that an hour is coming “and now is”—notice the verb tenses: an hour IS COMING in the future and NOW IS—present at the time when Jesus was on earth and present for each reader who reads this—when the dead will hear the voice of the Son and God, and those who hear will live. “The dead” is referring to those who are spiritually dead. The spiritually dead is every one of us by nature; we are all born dead in sin and objects of God’s wrath (Ephesians 2:1–3). The dead who “hear” His voice will live—just as He said in verse 24.
He further explains that to Him as the Son of Man—God the Son incarnate—the Father has granted intrinsic life. He Himself has life and has the authority to execute judgment because He has taken the place of us as our Substitute. He was born spiritually alive, conceived by the Holy Spirit, and was never dead in sin as the rest of us humans are by nature. As the perfect, spiritually alive Son of Man, He has taken humanity’s imputed sin, and he has already died for sin and satisfied God’s death sentence.
Then, in verse 28, He explains the resurrection of the body. Notice that in verse 25 he doesn’t refer to “resurrection”. He only says that the “dead will hear the voice of the Son of God, and those who hear will live.” This is a statement of passing spiritually out of death into eternal life when we believe and trust Jesus. This is the description of being born again.
In Verse 29, though, He specifically says “resurrection”. In verse 28 He says, “an hour is coming…” but notice that, unlike verse 25, He does not say “and now is”. He is referring to a time still future, and he specifically says the tombs will be opened when they hear His voice. There will be two categories of people who come out of the tombs in the future: the righteous to “a resurrection of life” and the wicked “to a resurrection of judgment”.
He has already said that those who believe Him pass out of death into life and do not come into judgment. Those who have believed and have been born again spiritually will still die physically, but they will be resurrected to a resurrection of life. There will be no dealing with sin at this resurrection. Those who did not believe, however, will be resurrected to judgment. We learn from Revelation 20 that those resurrected for judgment will be sentenced to the lake of fire.
In other words, people who trust Jesus move out of our natural state of spiritual death into life. We are sealed with the Holy Spirit (Ephesians 1:13–14), and we will never die or come into judgment because our Lord Jesus has been judged for our sin and has died and taken our curse of death. He has shattered our death sentence by His resurrection; all He has done will be credited to us.
Those who do not believe will be resurrected for judgment. They will receive on themselves the wrath of God for their sins which Jesus took on Himself for we who believe. †
Write to: proclamation@gmail.com
- Biblical Verdict: Ellen White Failed (Q4 L9) - November 19, 2026
- We Got Mail - November 19, 2026
- The Claim: Bible Only—The Practice: Ellen White (Q4 L8) - November 12, 2026